PDA

View Full Version : i wana go on the all carb diet, which one do u recommend? ;)



turn69up
25th February 2011, 03:08 PM
i wana go the carby route with my big port 4age so far i have come up with the one im looking for...(i think) LOL.
its off the suzuki GSXR 1100 and the kawasaki ZX-900 and ZX-1100 its called a "keihin FCR 41mm inline 4 horazontal, flat side, downdraft"
1st- is this the one i want?
2nd- are there any others that will work?
3rd- will the 38mm version do as i want the 41mm but think its a bit harder to find?
4th- how much should i pay found a few in the states for like $800
5th ?... is there any thing i should know going this route (i know i will need to tune them regulaurly)
6th im tired of trolling:sleepy:
7th thanks for any info :)

anastasios
25th February 2011, 03:49 PM
I suggest more research, 4age is designed to be an efi engine

Andy San
25th February 2011, 03:52 PM
any carbies other than the dcoe webers will be expensive to set up and get working properly as jets and chokes etc are getting hard to get for them.
Especially when you are trying to swap them of two very different motors.

38mm is very small, keep in mind the silvertop throttle bodies are 42mm (or are they 40mm- i forget).

You can get a new set of DCOE webers for a little more, you will be able to buy an off the shelf manifold for them and linkages that will actually work well. Plus you can get them setup by someone who will actually know what they are dealing with.

anastasios
25th February 2011, 03:54 PM
http://www.club4ag.com/faq_and_tech_pages/Carburators_4A-GE.htm#Some carburetor setups:

blinded
25th February 2011, 04:01 PM
Twin DCOEs or DHLAs.

Don't expect much change from $2000 - $2500 if you want them to be setup properly.

worked
25th February 2011, 04:50 PM
ask joshke he has R1 carbs om his 4ag
best setup i've seen on an NA 4ag

turn69up
25th February 2011, 07:54 PM
thanks guys

JoshKE
25th February 2011, 08:17 PM
As Ed said, I'm running R1 carbs on my 4AG. One of the biggest issues you will run into is getting a custom manifold made. If you're handy with alloy welding and have loads of time on your hands give it a go, as bike carbs are great things. I'm still in the middle of tuning mine, mucking around with jet sizes and needle size and height. But with being such a modern carb, jets and needles are easy to get a hold of. Even with the rough state of my tune, I can turn the key and have it spring to life like an EFI setup.

Having said that... if you haven't got someone to do the manifold work for you without shaking you down for all the cash you have, I would go for DCOE carbs like Webers.

If you have a bigport 4A this kit gets you most of the way, minus tune, filters, etc.

http://www.weberperformance.com.au/product_info.php?cPath=2_82&products_id=291

If you're totally set on carb'ing the 4A you will also have to look into ignition setups for it. A bunch in NZ make a little ignition module (Hyperpak, you can find them on eBay for a decent price usually, $200-300) that runs off the standard distributor giving an advance curve of 15 deg from the static timing. Other than that you have locked timing setups which aren't as good but are cheap and do the job, then there is setups involving custom distributors, fancy modules like MSD/Mallorys/etc, which cost more.

Basically, bike carbs are do-able, if you've got the time/money to spend.

turn69up
26th February 2011, 01:38 PM
sweet thanks joshke ive found some off a GSXR 1100 for $300 probs gonna get them :)

turn69up
26th February 2011, 01:40 PM
+ got a mate who is a mad sheet metal apprentice

turn69up
26th February 2011, 09:47 PM
I suggest more research, 4age is designed to be an efi engine


http://www.hachiroku.com.au/blog/?p=3493 some interesting quotes from that link

''Coming injected and dual over head cam (or twin cam) from the factory, many of the Japanese tuners at the time didn’t really know how to get much more power out of this mysterious box of resistors and wires.So what did they do? They turned to what they new best by taking off the injection manifold and strapping on a set of carbs!!''

''Even today in japan its a almost a 50-50 split between carbs and injection for a 4A-GE engine. Mostly due to workshops having limited access to a dyno’s to correctly tune an injection engine, so using a set of bike carbs and tuning on the road is the best thing they’ve got.
Even in the top level N2 races almost half the field use multiple carb setups and tune the cars by ear. Most of these are privateers but there is still a number of large well known work shops using multiple carbs''

Deeken
24th March 2011, 02:19 PM
Hmm was considering setting up carbys on my 16v bigport.. but if it's shit expensive/difficult to do I don't really wanna deal with the headache, especially with what I'm going to have to do cutting apart the tail gate to fix rust..

OniKyan
24th March 2011, 03:11 PM
I would suggest the 40mm Mikuni CV off a 98-01 Yamaha R1. They won't make quite as much power as the FCR carbs, however, their power delivery will be much smoother. They're also about $200-$300 for a set of four off eBay.

LittleRedSpirit
25th March 2011, 12:06 PM
If you ask me the Kehin FCR is the rolls royce of carbs when it comes to response. I'm really impressed with how the FCR works on my moto, and I've been thinking for a while this would be nice.

I've been looking around for info for a while.

AFAIK the mysterious Jay from Buddyparts had some in his AE86 and it seemed to go as good as any 4age in his drift vids.
There is a manifold for AE86 4age available from RS Chita but its pricey just like all their parts.
I heard there is tuning info for them in the TRD bible but I dont have the document to confirm this.

Id be looking at 41s for a 1600. It should do it fine with the right jetting. My moto is 450cc and runs off a single FCR 41mm up to 11500 rpm, so in general volumetric terms it should be tuneable with a revvy 1600 no problem at all.

The sets of 4x41mm carbs you see on superbikes are usually aftermarket kits. New kits are around 1200US and will be jetted to suit a moto and need correcting.

So as far as costs go, the manifold is $500 or so.
The 4 carbs could be $600 to $1200 US depending whether you use new or used.
They will have a TPS available so you can run a programmable ignition computer. I think MSD makes a good one. Maybe another $500 to sort this out.
Some coils, perhaps another $50-$300 depending on what you choose.
Then you will need fuel line, a low pressure pump, another $100 worth of jets and carby accessories.
$200+ for some velocity stacks of a decent length.

Obviously the smart money is finding an AE86 specific FCR setup on a running motor. Its about as expensive as EFI to get going, if not more so, but I think it would make a different noise, make good if not great power and deliver it well compared to an efi system. Its the best way to get slide style openings into your inlet without making some custom slide throttles I think. There are a lot of veocity stacks for them, but most are small in length, wonder if anyone makes variable length stacks for them...

OniKyan
25th March 2011, 04:19 PM
If you ask me the Kehin FCR is the rolls royce of carbs when it comes to response. I'm really impressed with how the FCR works on my moto, and I've been thinking for a while this would be nice.



Indeed. Keihin FCR or Mikuni RS would be the best, however, Keihin CVK and Mikuni CV(OEM for sport bikes) would provide almost the same flow at WOT, with a much more friendly low end and power delivery, (much better for street). The carbs themselves are about 1/4 the cost, which for the average Corolla owner, could be seen as a huge benefit.

Cheap, huge improvement over single throttle injection and they both, look and sound porn.

Hy9xZZtg5Aw

LittleRedSpirit
25th March 2011, 05:37 PM
Its not just about how much air they flow but the turbulence of the air too.

Is there a particular reason why the CV carbs would idle better, and perform better at low revs? Im struggling to see why they would be superior at any point in the rpm band. I thought that was a matter of tuning and adjusment, no matter which one you use?

OniKyan
25th March 2011, 07:50 PM
Its not just about how much air they flow but the turbulence of the air too.

Is there a particular reason why the CV carbs would idle better, and perform better at low revs? Im struggling to see why they would be superior at any point in the rpm band. I thought that was a matter of tuning and adjusment, no matter which one you use?

I don't have any real-world experience with the FCR/RS type carb's but after countless hours of research into multi carburetor set-ups, the consensus seems to be that due to FCR/RS only having a slide, their throttle actuation is quick to the point where they can seem almost either on, or off. Therefore, a much more precise control of the throttle is required.

They also have an accelerator pump, so, If you open an FCR too fast, the engine can bog down as it allows too much flow/fuel for the given RPM. However with the CV, the throttle opens a butterfly, the suction of the open butterfly actuates the slide as necessary. Theoretically this doesn't allow the same kind of over fueling that you can get from the Flat Slide carbs.

Hope that makes sense, I'm not really an expert on the matter.

jfallen
26th March 2011, 06:12 PM
CV cabies are more like a multiple SU setup and the carburetors operate on much the same principle. CV standing for Constant Velocity. Thus across the Dashpot (SU) or Slide (CV) the air speed remains the same at all times (unless the carbie is too small or at WOT.) In both cases the engine air is regulated by a butterfly type throttle body located between the engine head and the dashpot/slide.

While CV's don't have a "Choke" or "Venturi" in the traditional sense the air pressure between the throttle plate and the dashpot/slide like air speed remains constant, except in some cases of WOT. What I've said thus far is all true for steady state "cruise" motoring. What happens when you snap the throttle open??

Well, DCOE's and FCR's have an accelerator pump to make the mixture richer. CV's and SU's don't as mentioned prior. Now I'm working this out from memory on my Datsun 180B with twin SU's :D to here goes:

1: Snap Throttle Open.
2: As pressure drops between the throttle plate and the Dashpot the "wants’" to rise, this is resisted by a tuned spring and dashpot oil acting in a damping circuit.
3: The rising dashpot allows more air into the engine, and as it rises exposes an ever thinner needle cross section allowing more fuel into the engine.
4: As the Dashpot is resisted form rising by the spring and the damping circuit, the air speed across the venturi increases and the pressure drops thus increasing the Draw on fuel.
4.1: This resistance isn't much but it's enough. If you don't have oil in the dashpot or a too light a spring then it'll back fire as the mixture is too lean.
5: As the engine reaches steady state the dashpot begins to fall leaning out the mixture to an appropriate amount

6: For this reason SU's and CV's never feel as sharp (no matter how good a setup.) on throttle response as DCOE's or FCR's, as on initial acceleration a slight restriction is placed on the inlet in order to draw in more fuel to prevent backfires. That's not to say they feel "Doey," my old 180b was much, much sharper with Twin SU's than the previous 32/36 DVGA, but I wish I'd put the Twin 40mm Solex PPH setup on. Unfortunately it was not to be.
6.1: However this ever constant adjustment is why SU's tend to return excellent fuel economy, often on par with EFI when set up well with that in mind. Obviously if you set them up for performance like the MG crowd then well, they're like any performance Carb setup; Crappy on fuel.

Hope this was useful
Jordan

P.S: As a shameless plug: I've currently got a Twin 40mm PPH Solex setup for a 4AGE, it includes:

-Matched pair of 2 40mm PPH Solex Carburetors (Twin dual throat side drafts)
-These are tuned for a mild 2TG that was buzzing 8000RPM
-4AGE big port DCOE manifold
-Throttle linkage (NEW)
-Velocity Stacks (trumpets) (NEW)
-Air Filter Socks (NEW)

If anyone in interested give me a holler: manitoublack@gmail.com or PM.

OniKyan
6th April 2011, 08:20 PM
mgFBK3VdAW8

Keihin 36 or 38mm CVK's.

All relevant information to the tune/set up is posted in the YouTube information, however, Justin said he has now changed the main jets from 150's to 210's.

turn69up
15th August 2011, 01:55 AM
Thanks guys lots of great info there i bought some dellorto dhla carbies with a jap manifold (the brand eludes me at this hour) but they are the "emission" type, hope fully can just change 1 part to get them to be the "performance" type + need some linkages etc so putting that aside for now (plan to have a few carbie 4age equiped cars) and go with the r1's carbies as i can get some for an ok price and manifold would be really easy to make. Jut one more question i have desided to go the hyperpak route but they want to know if i a 3 or 4 wire dizzy i know what that means but i dont have a dizzy yet and was about to buy just the 3 wire type as its for a big port and would just buy a bp dizzy but was thinking would that exta wire be usefull? As in i wana run a rev limeter an know u need a carbie spesific one but would that extra wire let me run a normal one ie Bee*R :D