its not the same. driving gtr's, wrx's, nissan 2L's dont have the same feel. much more comfortabe but not the same.
only newer car id happily own instead of a ae86 is a mx5 but id want a hardtop.
havent had any experience with s2000's but i hear theyre nice but over-rated especially for the price.
just go to your nearest capital capital cityand take some cars around for test drives from car lots. see if theres anything that tickles your fancy